White Captives: Gender and Ethnicity on the American Frontier (English Language and Literature; 140)

Namias shows that visual, literary, and historical accounts of the capture of Euro-Americans by Indians are commentaries on the uncertain boundaries of gender, race, and culture during the colonial Indian Wars, the American Revolution, and the Civil War. She compares the experiences and representations of male and female captives over time and on successive frontiers and examines the narratives of captives Jane McCrea, Mary Jemison, and Sarah Wakefield.

White Captives offers a new analysis of Indian-white coexistence on the American frontier. June Namias shows that visual, literary, and historical accounts of the capture of Euro-Americans by Indians during the colonial Indian Wars, the American Revolution, and the Civil War are commentaries on the uncertain boundaries of gender, race, and culture. She demonstrates that these captivity materials, which most often feature as victims white women and children (the most vulnerable members of their communities), vividly portray anxieties about gender and ethnicity on the frontier and in American society. Namias begins by comparing the experiences and representations of male and female captives over time and on successive frontiers, from colonial New England to mid-nineteenth-century Minnesota, and explores how the stories transformed victims of historical circumstance into heroes and heroines. She then uses the narratives of three captives - Jane McCrea, Mary Jemison, and Sarah Wakefield - as case studies, arguing that they describe the fears of sexual contact between native cultures and white settlers and illustrate issues of female survival, independence, and competence. Moreover, she finds that these and other stories also reflect the major role of women and children in the migration process. According to Namias, both the historical reality and the reworked tales of capture offered white Americans new ways of looking at gender and ethnic relations by contrasting their own roles and value with those presumed to be Indian. Thus, while elements of horror, propaganda, mythmaking, and ethnographic documentary characterized the accounts, captivity materials served a larger purpose by providing a framework for notions of gender and cultural conflict on the frontier.

Library Journal

Namias's study is a carefully researched and scholarly account of the captivity experience in early America. Migration brought the European settlers and the Indians together in a variety of cross-cultural encounters. Namias (history, Univ. of Alaska-Anchorage) divides her study into two main parts: the first gives the reader an overview of the captivity experience from the viewpoint of both men and women and also includes a chapter on the sexual relationships between these groups. The second part is specific to the stories of three captives--Jane McCrea, Mary Jemison, and Sarah Wakefield. Namias explores the myths and realities in the relationship between the white settlers and the Native cultures. Her work will have great appeal to scholars and to readers with a keen interest in these aspects of American frontier history.-- Dorothy Lil ly, Grosse Pointe North H.S., Grosse Pointe Woods, Mich.