The Myth Of The Male Breadwinner: Women And Industrialization In The Caribbean (Conflict and Social Change Series)

This book examines the debate about the effects of industrialization and paid employment on gender inequality, based on the author’s studies of women industrial workers in Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, and Cuba. Safa focuses on three areas of these women's lives: wages and working conditions; the family, life cycle, and household composition; and political consciousness and participation in unions, political parties, and other mass organizations. She finds that women workers have been more effective in challenging their subordination in the home than they have been in the workplace and in relationship to political parties or the state. This finding challenges feminist theories that locate the sources of women’s inequality solely in the family, suggesting that the myth of the male breadwinner still prevails in the workplace and in state policy. Today there is a growing debate about the effects of paid employment on women. Some observers argue that paid employment is the key to gender equality because it raises women’s class consciousness and reduces their isolation within the home and their dependence on a male’s wages. Others suggest that paid employment merely increases women’s burden and reinforces their subordination, locking them into poorly paid, dead-end jobs.This book examines the debate through studies of women industrial workers in Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, and Cuba. The percentage of women in the labor force has grown rapidly in all three countries since 1970, but each country represents a radically different model of development. Puerto Rico’s Operation Bootstrap was a forerunner of other “industrialization by invitation” strategies in the region, and the Dominican Republic represents a classic case of recently initiated, rapidly growing export manufacturing under the Caribbean Basin Initiative. Socialist Cuba continued to rely on sugar exports as a source of foreign exchange and on import substitution industrialization for the domestic economy. However, Cuba has made special efforts to incorporate women into the labor force and has made women’s equality a key goal of its revolutionary strategy.The book focuses on three areas of these women’s lives: wages and working conditions; the family, life cycle, and household composition; and political consciousness and participation in unions, political parties, and other mass organizations. Women are now making a critical contribution to the household economy, attributable in part to the growth of labor-intensive industrialization in the region. The increase in women’s wage-earning capacity is reflected in authority patterns and in women’s greater control over the household budget. However, women continue to be confined to poorly paid jobs and to be marginalized by political parties and labor unions, which persist in regarding them as supplementary wage earners. Women workers have been more effective in challenging their subordination in the home than they have been in the workplace and in relationship to political parties or the state. This finding challenges feminist theories that locate the sources of women’s inequality solely in the family and suggests that such theories need to be augmented by studies of subordination at the level of the workplace and of state policy. "Comparative sociohistorical study examines interplay of the economy and gender relationships in Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Dominican Republic. Offers extended treatment of the impact of Operation Bootstrap on Puerto Rican women and gender relationships, the impact on women of the Dominican Republic's economic crisis and export manufacturing option of the 1980s, and the development of mass organizations for women in Cuba"--Handbook of Latin American Studies, v. 57. First Published in 2018. This book examines the debate about the effects of paid employment on women through studies of women industrial workers in Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, and Cuba. It focuses on following areas of women's lives: wages and working conditions; the family, life cycle, and household composition. A study of women industrial workers in Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic and Cuba. The author concludes that women workers in these three areas of the Caribbean have been more effective in challenging their own subordination in the privacy of the home than in the public one of work and politics.