The Ethics of Courage : Volume 1: From Greek Antiquity to the Middle Ages

This two-volume work examines far-reaching debates on the concept of courage from Greek antiquity to the Christian and mediaeval periods, as well as the modern era. Volume 1 begins with Homeric poetry and the politics of fearless demi-gods thriving on war. The tales of lion-hearted Heracles, Achilles, and Ulysses, and their tragic fall at the hands of fate, eventually give way to classical views of courage based on competing theories of rational wisdom and truth. Fears of the enemy and anxieties about suffering and death are addressed through the lenses and teachings of medicine, geography, military history, moral philosophy, and metaphysics. For early Christian thinkers, the ethics of fear, fate, and fealty to the Almighty supplant the voice of reason and the wisdom of virtue. Much of Christian doctrine's history is a long journey towards bridging the gap between Greek philosophy and devotion to God and spirits in heaven. Some Church Fathers attempt to dispel the fear of suffering through a joyful craving for martyrdom and the eternal blessings that follow. Others show openness to one or more of the following principles: the abstractions of moral philosophy, the metaphysics of Gnostic enlightenment, the gift of free will and intentionality, the growth of church authority and hegemony, and the intrinsic worth of life on Earth. Augustine, Ambrose, Cassian, and Chrysostom play a central role in revisiting the foundations of Christian fortitude along some or all of these lines. They lay the groundwork for the scholastic adaptations of faith-based rationalism proposed by Peter Lombard, Philip the Chancellor, Albert the Great, and Thomas of Aquinas. The mediaeval period ends with church dissidents and Protestant Reform leaders condemning Rome’s corruption and calling for a return to early Christian faith and the courage of godly fear, submission, suffering, and fate. MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict Contents 6 1: The Roots of Courage 10 Life, Power, and Truth 10 The Origins of Courage 15 Courage Throughout History 20 Methodological Remarks 25 Reference 26 2: Fearlessness and Fate in Ancient Greece 27 Lion-hearted Heracles, Achilles, and Ulysses 27 Women Without Fear: Euripides, Sophocles, and Aristophanes 34 Euripides 34 Sophocles 40 Aristophanes 42 References 44 3: Soldierly Courage and Wisdom 46 The Invention of History: Herodotus and Thucydides 49 Facts and Fables of World History: Diodorus of Sicily 60 The Laws of Physis: From Hippocrates to Galen 69 References 72 4: Wisdom Above Soldierly Courage 74 The Unity and Rank-ordering of Virtue: Plato 74 Education and Battles for Justice: Isocrates and Lysias 82 Aristotle’s Happy Mean 85 The Art of Persuasion: Demosthenes 91 Physis, Polis, and Logos 98 References 101 5: Wisdom as Courage 104 Socrates Questioning 104 Questioning Socrates 117 References 122 6: The Courage of Natural Living 124 The Wisdom of Simple Pleasures: Epicurus 124 Freedom from Irrational Passions: Stoicism 131 References 145 7: Courage, Wisdom, and Mysticism 147 Ascending to the Divine: Pythagoreanism 148 The All-Soul and the Divine Intellect: Porphyry and Plotinus 152 Jewish Piety and Perfection of the Soul: Philo of Alexandria 157 References 162 8: Fear and Love in Early Christianity 164 Strength in Fear and Faith in the Holy Writ 166 Fear of God and Fearless Martyrdom 173 Gnostic Love and the Futility of Courage 178 References 183 9: Living, Conquering, and Ruling 186 Self-killing and Martyrdom: Clement of Rome and Athanasius 188 Victorious Rulers and Soldiers of Christ 191 Beyond Fear and Faith-based Courage 200 References 201 10: Overtures to Reason and the Gift of Love 204 Wavering Between Reason and Religion: Origen and Lactantius 205 Virtue Received from God: Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine of Hippo 211 References 221 11: Freedom and the Wisdom of Love and Fortitude 225 Paradise and Fortitude of the Mind: Ambrose 226 Conscience, Fear, and Love: John Cassian and John Chrysostom 232 References 247 12: Courage in the Early Middle Ages and Islam 251 Varieties of Courage in Gethsemane 252 Courage in the Early Middle Ages 257 Islam in Greek Garb: Averroes (Ibn Rushd) 263 References 273 13: Crusading and Dying for Christ 275 Fear and War: Bernard of Clairvaux and Ramon Llull 275 Logic, Causality, and Metaphor: Bonaventure 279 God, Courage, and the Common Good: Avicenna and Albert the Great 287 References 292 14: Reason, Faith, and Charity 294 Levels of Fear and Love: Peter Lombard 294 Courage Perfected with Divine Love: Philip the Chancellor 299 God, Reason, Justice, and Fortitude: Thomas Aquinas 304 References 313 15: Intentionality and Powers of the Will 314 Charity and Intentional Consent: Peter Abelard 316 The Will Above All Else: Duns Scotus 322 Fighting Off and Enduring What Needs to Be Fought and Endured 324 The Mind Proposes, the Will Disposes 325 The Body Predisposes, the Will Disposes 329 Charity as the Highest Perfection of the Will 332 Evil Can Be Willed: William of Ockham 337 References 340 16: Challenging and Reforming the Church 342 The Selfless Love of Catherine of Siena and Bridget of Sweden 343 Predestination, Filial Fear, and the Unfaithful Church: John Wyclif 347 Love Out of Faith and Fear: Martin Luther 351 Fortitude Without Merit: Jean Calvin 357 References 366 17: Custodians of the Earth 367 Tribulation and Humble Faith: Thomas More 368 Utopia and Life on Earth 371 The Throne Shall Never be Empty 376 References 380