The Dangers of Ritual : Between Early Medieval Texts and Social Scientific Theory

Central to current understandings of medieval history is the concept of political ritual, encompassing events from coronations to funerals, entries into cities, civic games, banquets, hunting, acts of submission or commendation, and more. 'Ritual?' asks Philippe Buc. In 'The Dangers of Ritual' he boldly argues that the concept shouldn't be so central after all. Modern-day scholars, gently seduced by twentieth-century theories of ritual, often misinterpret medieval documents that ostensibly describe such events, in part because they fail to appreciate the intentions behind them. The book begins with four case studies whose arrangement - backward from texts on tenth-century kingship to fourth-century representations of Christian martyrdom - allows for the line of development to be peeled back layer by layer. It then turns to an analysis of the formation of the intellectual traditions that contemporary historians have employed to interpret medieval documents. Tracing the emergence of the concept of ritual from the Reformation to the mid-twentieth century, Buc highlights the continuities yet also the profound transformations between the early medieval understandings and our own, social-scientific models. Medieval historians will find this book an indispensable resource for its insights into methodological issues crucial to their discipline. As Buc demonstrates, only rigorous attention to the contexts within which authors worked can allow us to reconstruct from medieval documents how 'rituals' might have functioned. Ultimately, he argues, too swift an application of contemporary models to highly complex textual artifacts blinds us to the specificities of early medieval European political culture. Preface vii Abbreviations ix Introduction 1 Part I: Late Antique and Early Medieval Narratives 13 Chapter One. Writing Ottoman Hegemony: Good Rituals and Bad Rituals in Liudprand of Cremona 15 Chapter Two. Ritual Consensus and Ritual Violence: Texts and Events in Ninth-Century Carolingian Political Culture 51 Chapter Three. Rites of Saints and Rites of Kings: Consensus and Transgression in the Works of Gregory of Tours 88 Chapter Four. The Late Antique Matrix: Martyrdom and Ritual 123 Part II: From Theology to the Social Sciences, ca. 1500 - ca. 1970 159 Chapter Five. Rites, Rituals, and Order, ca. 1500 - ca. 1800 164 Chapter Six. Medieval History and the Social Sciences, ca. 1800 - ca. 1970 203 Chapter Seven. Epilogue 248 Index 263 "Medieval historians will find this book an indispensable resource for its insights into methodological issues crucial to their discipline. As Buc demonstrates, only rigorous attention to the contexts within which authors worked can allow us to reconstruct from medieval documents how "rituals" might have functioned. Ultimately, he argues, too swift an application of contemporary models to highly complex textual artifacts blinds us to the specificities of early medieval European political culture."--BOOK JACKET. RELATIVE TO its competitors and neighbors, the Ottonian dynasty (919-1024) enjoyed remarkable success.