Rituals of the past : prehispanic and colonial case studies in Andean archaeology

The use of the plural term rituals in the title of this volume points to the variety of theoretical and methodological approaches to the study of ritual in anthropology and archaeology. One approach to the study of ritual has been to follow a theoretical view based primarily on practice theory, which posits that the structure of daily life serves as a small-scale reflection of the broader organizational tenets of society (Bourdieu 1977). This perspective aligns with the argument made in religious studies by Bell (1992) and later reinforced in anthropology by Moore (2005) that ritual action and ritual belief cannot be separated. Ritual is viewed as more than just action, but one wholly embedded within the larger social structure of the particular society. In this sense, this practice approach opened the platform for studying ritual from an everyday life perspective and away from an emphasis on monumental archaeological sites. Some of the case studies in this volume, while not necessarily following this theoretical perspective, do discuss ritual in a variety of non-monumental contexts, including mountain-pass shrines (Nielsen, Angiorama, and Ávila), quarry mines (Van Gijseghem and Whalen), and small architectural structures (Contreras). The Andes, a succession of parallel and transverse mountain ranges, or cordilleras, extend over the modern-day South American countries of Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, Venezuela, Chile, and Argentina. The archaeological record demonstrates that the Andes were the backdrop of some of the world’s bestknown prehispanic cultures (e.g., Nasca, Moche, Inka). Moreover, we know from ethnohistorical, ethnographic, and anthropological sources that ritual was a key component in the formation and maintenance of many of these prehispanic societies, as well as of present-day Andean indigenous communities (Abercrombie 1998; Bolin 1998; Isbell 1978). Many scholars have observed that some of the ritual practices and traditions are continuations from prehispanic times. For example, the present-day worship of the Andean mountains (apus) has been documented throughout many Andean areas (Allen 1988; Anders 1986; Bolin 1998; Reinhard 1985), and ethnohistorical documents indicate that the Inka also practiced this type of ritual (Gose 1986; Kuznar 2001). Andean archaeologists have used this evidence to make archaeological inferences about pre-Inka apu worshipping practices for societies such as the Wari (ad 550–950) (e.g., Glowacki and Malpass 2003; Moseley 2001; Williams and Nash 2006). While the rituals may have continued through time, their meanings were constantly reconstructed. Following this tradition, some case studies in this volume deal with certain rituals (e.g., termination rituals, apacheta/ cairn worship, and mountain worship) that appear to have been recurrent in many parts of the Andes as fluid and dynamic practices (Edwards; Nielsen, Angiorama, and Ávila, Van Gijseghem and Whalen, this volume). Through the study of archaeological, ethnographic, linguistic, and historical evidence from northern Peru to northern Chile, Bolivia, and northwest Argentina, the authors in this volume show the significance of ritual from precontact to the present day in the Andes. The volume, however, does not follow one specific theoretical or methodological approach; instead, broad topics are of concern to many of the contributors. The analysis of Andean ceremonial architecture to infer power relationships is present in many of the case studies (e.g., Abraham, Chicoine et al., Edwards, Fernandini and Ruales, this volume). This is not surprising, given that the social effort implied in public construction can be understood as a reflection of power (Moore 1996:3) andAN ARCHAEOLOGy OF RITUALS 11 also because people’s values and beliefs shaped Andean architecture (ibid.:123). However, current research (Bray 2015; Meddens et al. 2014) has demonstrated that rituals can be performed beyond architectural walls and in a variety of entities. Some of the authors in this volume demonstrate this phenomenon; Nielsen and colleagues discuss rituals at mountain passes and apachetas, and Van Gijseghem and Whalen focus on rituals inside mines. Other scholars, while focusing mostly on architecture, connect rituals in human-nature engagements such as with canals and water (Rick, this volume) and floors and fire (Onuki, this volume). Another important topic is the relationship between Andean cosmologies and social memory (e.g., Onuki; Nielsen, Angiorama, and Ávila; Van Gijseghem and Whalen, this volume). The chapters in this book demonstrate how the archaeological study of ritual activity can help us better understand past ideology, site function, elite strategies of power, local adaptations to colonialism, and perceptions of space and landscape. The chapters in this volume are organized based on common themes and loosely chronological associations. Of course, other divisions could have been possible, since some similar topics (e.g., the study of structured depositions) crosscut different theoretical approaches and time periods. However, a chronological order was needed since the essays deal with data from one large region: the Andes. The volume begins with a discussion of ritual to understand cosmologies and ideologies during Chavín times in present-day Peru. After discussing the taphonomy of ritual evidence at Chavín de Huántar, John Rick details a variety of ritual locations, which include pits, construction fills, and, most notably, underground galleries and canals. While the canals functioned to drain and supply water, Rick interprets the complex design and content of part of the canals as places where water-related rituals took place. The concentration of complete but smashed vessels at the conjunction of canals is understood as an indication of possible locations of ritual sacrifice. Situating his interpretation within specific Andean cosmology, Rick suggests that these particular contexts could have represented the Andean belief tinku: the ritual encounter of water and people. These water-related rituals were perhaps performed to control the risks and outcomes involving water’s energy, which would have been part of the complex belief system at the temple of Chavín. Explores Various Methods Archaeologists Use To Identify Ritual In The Material Record And Discusses The Influence It Had On The Formation, Reproduction, And Transformation Of Community In Past Andean Societies. How Ritual Influenced, Permeated, And Altered Political Authority, Economic Production, Shamanic Practice, And Landscape Cognition Over 3,000 Years--provided By Publisher. An Archaeology Of Rituals / Silvana A. Rosenfeld And Stefanie L. Bautista -- The Nature Of Ritual Space At Chavín De Huantar / John Rick -- Not Just A Pyramid Scheme : Diversity In Ritual Architecture At Chavín De Huantar / Daniel Contreras -- From Ritual To Ideology : Ritual Activity And Artistic Representations In The Northern Highlands Of Peru In The Formative Period / Yoshio Onuki -- Architecture And Ritual Practices At Huaca A Of Pampa De Las Llamas- Moxeke / Rafael Vega-centeno -- Territoriality, Monumentality, And Religion In Formative Period Nepeña, Coastal Áncash / David Chicoine, Hugo Ikebara, And Koichiro Shibata, And Matthew Helmer -- Ritual Practice At The End Of Empire : Evidence Of An Abandonment Ceremony From Pataraya, A Wari Outpost On The South Coast Of Peru / -- Matthew Edwards -- From The Domestic To The Formal : A View Of Daily And Ceremonial Practices From Cerro De Oro During The Early Middle Horizon / Francesca Fernandini And Rafael Ruales -- The Demise Of The Ruling Elites : Terminal Rituals In The Pyramid Complexes Of Panquilma, Peruvian Central Coast / Camila Capriata Estrada And Enrique Lopez-hurtado -- Reconstructing Early Colonial Andean Ritual Practice At Pucará, Peru : An Architectural Approach / Sarah Abraham -- Ritual As Inter-action With Non-humans : Pre-hispanic Mountain Pass Shrines In The Southern Andes / Axel Nielsen, Carlos Angiorama, And Florencia Avila -- Mining, Ritual, And Social Memory : An Exploration Of Toponymy In The Ica Valley, Peru / Hendrik Van Gijseghem And Verity Whalen -- Rituals Of The Past : Final Comments / Jerry D. Moore. Edited By Silvana A. Rosenfeld And Stefanie L. Bautista. Includes Bibliographical References And Index. List of Figures vii List of Tables xiii 1. An Archaeology of Rituals Silvana A. Rosenfeld and Stefanie L. Bautista 3 2. The Nature of Ritual Space at Chavín de Huántar John W. Rick 21 3. Not Just a Pyramid Scheme? Diversity in Ritual Architecture at Chavín de Huántar Daniel A. Contreras 51 4. From Ritual to Ideology: Ritual Activity and Artistic Representations in the Northern Highlands of Peru in the Formative Period Yoshio Onuki 79 5. Architecture and Ritual Practices at Huaca A of Pampa de las Llamas–Moxeke Rafael Vega-Centeno Sara-Lafosse 103 6. Territoriality, Monumentality, and Religion in Formative Period Nepeña, Coastal Ancash David Chicoine, Hugo Ikehara, Koichiro Shibata, and Matthew Helmer 123vi CONTENTS 7. Ritual Practice at the End of Empire: Evidence of an Abandonment Ceremony from Pataraya, a Wari Outpost on the South Coast of Peru Matthew J. Edwards 151 8. From the Domestic to the Formal: A View of Daily and Ceremonial Practices from Cerro de Oro during the Early Middle Horizon Francesca Fernandini and Mario Ruales 169 9. The Demise of the Ruling Elites: Terminal Rituals in the Pyramid Complexes of Panquilma, Peruvian Central Coast Camila Capriata Estrada and Enrique López-Hurtado 193 10. Reconstructing Early Colonial Andean Ritual Practice at Pukara, Peru: An Architectural Approach Sarah Abraham 217 11. Ritual as Interaction with Non-Humans: Prehispanic Mountain Pass Shrines in the Southern Andes Axel E. Nielsen, Carlos I. Angiorama, and Florencia Ávila 241 12.Mining, Ritual, and Social Memory: An Exploration of Toponymy in the Ica Valley, Peru Hendrik Van Gijseghem and Verity H. Whalen 267 13.Rituals of the Past: Final Comments Jerry D. Moore 295 List of Contributors 313 Index 315 Rituals of the Past explores the various approaches archaeologists use to identify ritual in the material record and discusses the influence ritual had on the formation, reproduction, and transformation of community life in past Andean societies. A diverse group of established and rising scholars from across the globe investigates how ritual influenced, permeated, and altered political authority, economic production, shamanic practice, landscape cognition, and religion in the Andes over a period of three thousand years. Contributors deal with theoretical and methodological concerns including non-human and human agency; the development and maintenance of political and religious authority, ideology, cosmologies, and social memory; and relationships with ritual action. The authors use a diverse array of archaeological, ethnographic, and linguistic data and historical documents to demonstrate the role ritual played in prehispanic, colonial, and post-colonial Andean societies throughout the regions of Peru, Chile, Bolivia, and Argentina. By providing a diachronic and widely regional perspective, Rituals of the Past shows how ritual is vital to understanding many aspects of the formation, reproduction, and change of past lifeways in Andean societies. Contributors: Sarah Abraham, Carlos Angiorama, Florencia Avila, Camila Capriata Estrada, David Chicoine, Daniel Contreras, Matthew Edwards, Francesca Fernandini, Matthew Helmer, Hugo Ikehara, Enrique Lopez-Hurtado, Jerry Moore, Axel Nielsen, Yoshio Onuki, John Rick, Mario Ruales, Koichiro Shibata, Hendrik Van Gijseghem, Rafael Vega-Centeno, Verity Whalen Through the study of archaeological, ethnographic, linguistic, and historical evidence from northern Peru to northern Chile, Bolivia, and northwest Argentina, the authors in this volume show the significance of ritual from pre-contact to present day in the Andes. These volume essays deal with theoretical and methodological concerns in anthropology and archaeology including non-human and human agency, the development and maintenance of political and religious authority, ideology, cosmologies, and social memory, and their relationships with ritual action. By providing a diachronic and widely regional perspective on ritual in the Andes, this volume shows how ritual is both persistent and dynamic and is key in understanding many aspects of the formation, reproduction, and change of life in past Andean societies.