Providence and personalism: Karl Barth in conversation with Austin Farrer, John Macmurray, and Vincent Brümmer

Karl Barth of fered Church Dogmatics III.3 as a ‘radical correction’ of Reformed Orthodoxy’s doctrine of providence. This book assesses this claim and argues that III.3 represents a ‘personalist’ revision of providence which can only be understood through Barth’s ad hoc use of philosophical resources. Barth’s doctrine of providence remains theology proper, and not philosophy, but cannot be understood without philosophy. Setting Barth in conversation with three philosophical theologians, Vincent Brümmer, John Macmurray and Austin Farrer, this book shows Barth’s distance from pre-modern understandings of providence. The conversations equip the reader to discern the continuities and discontinuities between III.3 and twentieth-century personal, relational philosophy, thereby making sense of many of Barth’s counterintuitive claims. Through contrast with the philosophical theologians, Barth’s Christocentric and Trinitarian articulation gains clarity and significance. Building on these philosophical comparisons, this book assesses Barth’s contributions to debates concerning history as determined by divine action, human freedom under providence and the problem of evil. Karl Barth Offered Church Dogmatics Iii.3 As A 'radical Correction' Of Reformed Orthodoxy's Doctrine Of Providence. This Book Assesses This Claim And Argues That Iii.3 Represents A 'personalist' Revision Of Providence Which Can Only Be Understood Through Barth's Ad Hoc Use Of Philosophical Resources. Barth's Doctrine Of Providence Remains Theology Proper, And Not Philosophy, But Cannot Be Understood Without Philosophy. Setting Barth In Conversation With Three Philosophical Theologians, Vincent Brümmer, John Macmurray And Austin Farrer, This Book Shows Barth's Distance From Pre-modern Understandings Of Providence. The Conversations Equip The Reader To Discern The Continuities And Discontinuities Between Iii.3 And Twentieth-century Personal, Relational Philosophy, Thereby Making Sense Of Many Of Barth's Counterintuitive Claims. Through Contrast With The Philosophical Theologians, Barth's Christocentric And Trinitarian Articulation Gains Clarity And Significance. Building On These Philosophical Comparisons, This Book Assesses Barth's Contributions To Debates Concerning History As Determined By Divine Action, Human Freedom Under Providence And The Problem Of Evil. Darren M. Kennedy. Includes Bibliographical References And Index. Karl Barth offered Church Dogmatics III. 3 as a 'radical correction' of Reformed Orthodoxy's doctrine of providence. This book assesses this claim and argues that III. 3 represents a 'personalist' revision of providence which can only be understood through Barth's ad hoc use of philosophical resources. Barth's doctrine of providence remains theology proper, and not philosophy, but cannot be understood without philosophy. Setting Barth in conversation with three philosophical theologians, Vincent Brümmer, John Macmurray and Austin Farrer, this book shows Barth's distance from pre-modern understandings of providence. The conversations equip the reader to discern the continuities and discontinuities between III. 3 and twentieth-century personal, relational philosophy, thereby making sense of many of Barth's counterintuitive claims. Through contrast with the philosophical theologians, Barth's Christocentric and Trinitarian articulation gains clarity and significance. Building on these philosophical comparisons, this book assesses Barth's contributions to debates concerning history as determined by divine action, human freedom under providence and the problem of evil Contents Acknowledgements vii Abbreviations ix Tables and Figures xi Chapter I Intoduction 1 Chapter II Prolegomena 9 Part I Conversations with Philosophical Theology 31 Chapter III The Persons of Providence in Barth and Brümmer 33 Chapter IV The Theological Form of the Personal in Barth and Macmurray 75 Chapter V Providential Double-Agency in Barth and Farrer 133 Church Dogmatics Using Tools from Philosophical Theology 191 Chapter VI §48 The Basis and Form of Providence 193 Chapter VII §49 God the Father as Lord of his Creature 209 Chapter VIII §50 God and Nothingness 259 Chapter IX §51 The Kingdom of Heaven, The Ambassadors of God and Their Opponents 283 Chapter X Conclusion 307 APPENDIX A Macmurray’s Description of Positive and Negative Aspects 315 Bibliography 317 Index 325