Peculiar Whiteness : Racial Anxiety and Poor Whites in Southern Literature, 1900-1965

"Peculiar Whiteness: Racial Anxiety and Poor Whites in Southern Literature, 1900-1965 argues for deeper consideration of the complexities surrounding the disparate treatment of poor whites throughout southern literature and attests to how broad such experiences have been. While the history of prejudice against this group is not the same as the legacy of violence perpetrated against people of color in America, individuals regarded as "white trash" have suffered a dehumanizing process in the writings of various white authors. Poor white characters are frequently maligned as grotesque and anxiety inducing, especially when they are aligned in close proximity to blacks or to people with disabilities. Thus, as a symbol, much has been asked of poor whites, and various iterations of the label (e.g., "white trash," tenant farmers, or even people with a little less money than average) have been subject to a broad spectrum of judgment, pity, compassion, fear, and anxiety. Peculiar Whiteness engages key issues in contemporary critical race studies, whiteness studies, and southern studies, both literary and historical. Through discussions of authors including Charles Chesnutt, Thomas Dixon, Sutton Griggs, Erskine Caldwell, Lillian Smith, William Faulkner, and Flannery O'Connor, we see how whites in a position of power work to maintain their status, often by finding ways to recategorize and marginalize people who might not otherwise have seemed to fall under the auspices or boundaries of "white trash.""-- Provided by publisher Peculiar Whiteness argues for deeper consideration of the complexities surrounding the disparate treatment of poor whites throughout southern literature and attests to how broad such experiences have been. While the history of prejudice against this group is not the same as the legacy of violence perpetrated against people of color in America, individuals regarded as ‘white trash’ have suffered a dehumanizing process in the writings of various white authors. Poor white characters are frequently maligned as grotesque and anxiety-inducing, especially when they are aligned in close proximity to blacks or with other troubling conditions such as physical difference. Thus, as a symbol, much has been asked of poor whites, and various iterations of the label (e.g., ‘white trash,’ tenant farmers, or even people with a little less money than average) have been subject to a broad spectrum of judgment, pity, compassion, fear, and anxiety. Peculiar Whiteness engages key issues in contemporary critical race studies, whiteness studies, and southern studies, both literary and historical. Through discussions of authors including Charles Chesnutt, Thomas Dixon, Erskine Caldwell, William Faulkner, and Flannery O’Connor, the book analyzes how we see how whites in a position of power work to maintain their status, often by finding ways to re-categorize and marginalize people who might not otherwise have seemed to fall under the auspices or boundaries of ‘white trash.’ Cover 1 PECULIAR WHITENESS 2 Title 4 Copyright 5 Dedication 6 CONTENTS 8 Note to Readers 10 Acknowledgments 12 INTRODUCTION 16 ONE Tom and Friends: Thomas Dixon, White Supremacy, and Poor Whites of the Lost Cause 36 TWO “It Ain’t Hardly Worth the Trouble to Go On Living”: The Reaction to Abject Poverty in Erskine Caldwell 66 THREE “Crashing to Bits”: Autobiographical Recreations of the South 104 FOUR “It Aint Nothing but Jest Another Snopes”: Boundaries of Whiteness in Yoknapatawpha 130 CONCLUSION Maimed Souls: O’Connor, Disability, and the Future of White Trash 154 Notes 166 Bibliography 194 ABOUT THE AUTHOR 206 A Deep, Compassionate Probing Of How White Writers Misconstrued, Manipulated, And Distrusted Poor Southern Whites