Noël Carroll and Film : A Philosophy of Art and Popular Culture

Noël Carroll is one of the most prolific, widely-cited and distinguished philosophers of art, but how, specifically, has cinema impacted his thought? This book, one of the first in the acclaimed 'Film Thinks' series, argues that Carroll's background in both cinema and philosophy has been crucial to his overall theory of aesthetics. Often a controversial figure within film studies, as someone who has assertively contested the psychoanalytic, semiotic and Marxist cornerstones of the field, his allegiance to alternative philosophical traditions has similarly polarised his readership. Mario Slugan proposes that Carroll's defence of the notions of truth and objectivity provides a welcome antidote to 'anything goes' attitudes and postmodern scepticism towards art and popular culture, including film. Carroll's thinking has loosened the grip of continental philosophers on cinema studies - from Maurice Merleau-Ponty to Gilles Deleuze and Jacques Lacan - by turning to cognitive and analytical approaches. Slugan goes further to reveal that Carroll's methods of evaluation and interpretation in fact, usefully bridge gaps between these `opposing' sides, to look at artworks anew. Throughout, Slugan revisits and enriches Carroll's definitions of popular art, mass art, horror, humour and other topics and concludes by tracing their origins to this important thinker's relationship with the medium of cinema. "Noel Carroll is one of the most prolific, widely-cited and distinguished philosophers of art, but how, specifically, has cinema impacted his thought? This book, one of the first in the acclaimed 'Film Thinks' series, argues that Carroll's background in both cinema and philosophy has been crucial to his overall theory of aesthetics. Often a controversial figure within film studies, as someone who has assertively contested the psychoanalytic, semiotic and Marxist cornerstones of the field, his allegiance to alternative philosophical traditions has similarly polarised his readership. Mario Slugan proposes that Carroll's defence of the notions of truth and objectivity provides a welcome antidote to 'anything goes' attitudes and postmodern scepticism towards art and popular culture, including film. Carroll's thinking has loosened the grip of continental philosophers on cinema studies - from Maurice Merleau-Ponty to Gilles Deleuze and Jacques Lacan - by turning to cognitive and analytical approaches. Slugan goes further to reveal that Carroll's methods of evaluation and interpretation in fact, usefully bridge gaps between these 'opposing' sides, to look at artworks anew. Throughout, Slugan revisits and enriches Carroll's definitions of popular art, mass art, horror, humour and other topics and concludes by tracing their origins to this important thinker's relationship with the medium of cinema"--Bloomsbury Collections Cover Author Biography Editorial Board Title Page Copyright Dedication Contents List of Illustrations Acknowledgements Introduction 1 Institutional Context The Relative Lack of Influence of Carroll’s Work on Film Studies The Institutional Reasons Behind Carroll’s Relative Lack of Influence Carroll’s Work on Ideology Carroll’s Rhetoric 2 Film Theory Contra Medium Specificity Against Monolithic Theories Cognitivism as Piecemeal Theorising 3 Assessment of Theory Irrelevance Straw Men Methodological Imperialism 4 Analytic and Cognitivist Debates Transparency Thesis The Moving Image Definition Implicit Fictional Film Narrators 5 Interpretation and Filmmaking Interpretation and Theoretical Commitments What Is Interpretation? From Interpretation to Theory Carroll’s Filmmaking 6 Philosophy of Art Anti-Essentialism The Philosophies of Arts Affective Responses to Art Conclusion Notes Bibliography Index