Leibniz on Individuals and Individuation: The Persistence of Premodern Ideas in Modern Philosophy (Philosophical Studies in Contemporary Culture, 3)

Leibniz's earliest philosophy and its importance for his mature philosophy have not been examined in detail, particularly in the level of detail that one can achieve by placing Leibniz's philosophy in the context of the sources for two of the most basic concerns of his philosophical career: his metaphysics of individuals and the principle oftheir individuation. In this book I provide for the first time a detailed examination of these two Leibnizian themes and trace its implications for how we should interpret other major Leibnizian themes and for how we should read Leibniz and other philosophers of the sixteenth and later centuries as 'modem' philosophers. Leibniz began his philosophical career more than 300 years ago, a fact that shapes fundamentally my attempt in the pages that follow to come to terms now with the texts that he left us. Leibniz's did not do philosophy in a way wholly congenial to twentieth century philosophical methodologies, especially those that have enjoyed some prominence in recent Anglo-American philosophy. Moreover, as we shall see, Leibniz is not a modem philosopher, when 'modem' is understood to mean making a sharp break with medieval philosophy. Indeed, I shall argue, scholars should discard such terms as 'modem' from historical philosophical scholarship, so that old texts can be allowed to remain old - to stand on their own in and from times now long past.

This book achieves a number of scholarly 'firsts': the first account of Leibniz's philosophy on individuals and the principle of individuation; the first exploration of Leibniz's earliest philosophy, its sources in later scholastic philosophy, and the influence of those sources on his mature philosophy; bringing together in one place numerous Latin scholastic and Leibnizian texts, with many translated into English. On the basis of a thorough study of Leibniz's earliest philosophy, a new interpretation of central themes in Leibniz's philosophy is offered. This scholarly investigation demonstrates the persistence of premodern ideas in modern philosophy, calling into question in what sense Leibniz is a 'modern' philosopher and how the 'modern' should be understood in modern philosophy and postmodernism. The intended audience includes historians of modern and later scholastic philosophy, Leibniz scholars, historians of ideas, philosophers with an interest in ontology and metaphysics, and graduate students in philosophy.

Front Matter....Pages i-xv Front Matter....Pages 1-1 Introduction to Leibniz’s Individuals and Their Individuation....Pages 3-21 Individuals and Individuation in the Disputatio ....Pages 22-33 The Principles of Individuation Leibniz Rejects in the Disputatio ....Pages 34-89 The Position Leibniz Defends in the Disputatio ....Pages 90-130 Front Matter....Pages 131-131 Individuals and Individuation in Leibniz’s Mature Philosophy....Pages 133-155 An Interpretation of Major Leibnizian Themes....Pages 156-179 Front Matter....Pages 181-181 Leibniz and the “Modern” in Modern Philosophy....Pages 183-199 Back Matter....Pages 201-210