Justice for Girls?: Stability and Change in the Youth Justice Systems of the United States and Canada (Adolescent Development and Legal Policy)

For over a century, as women have fought for and won greater freedoms, concern over an epidemic of female criminality, especially among young women, has followed. Fear of this crime wave—despite a persistent lack of evidence of its existence—has played a decisive role in the development of the youth justice systems in the United States and Canada. __Justice for Girls?__ is a comprehensive comparative study of the way these countries have responded to the hysteria over “girl crime” and how it has affected the treatment of both girls and boys. Tackling a century of historical evidence and crime statistics, Jane B. Sprott and Anthony N. Doob carefully trace the evolution of approaches to the treatment of young offenders. Seeking to keep youths out of adult courts, both countries have built their systems around rehabilitation. But, as Sprott and Doob reveal, the myth of the “girl crime wave” led to a punitive system where young people are dragged into court for minor offenses and girls are punished far more severely than boys. Thorough, timely, and persuasive, __Justice for Girls?__ will be vital to anyone working with troubled youths. For Over A Century, As Women Have Fought For And Won Greater Freedoms, Concern Over An Epidemic Of Female Criminality, Especially Among Young Women, Has Followed. Fear Of This Crime Wave - Despite A Persistent Lack Of Evidence Of Its Existence - Has Played A Decisive Role In The Development Of The Youth Justice Systems In The United States And Canada. Justice For Girls? Is A Comprehensive Comparative Study Of The Way These Countries Have Responded To The Hysteria Over Girl Crime And How It Has Affected The Treatment Of Both Girls And Boys. Tackling A Century Of Historical Evidence And Crime Statistics, Jane B. Sprott And Anthony N. Doob Carefully Trace The Evolution Of Approaches To The Treatment Of Young Offenders. Seeking To Keep Youths Out Of Adult Courts, Both Countries Have Built Their Systems Around Rehabilitation. But, As Sprott And Doob Reveal, The Myth Of The Girl Crime Wave Led To A Punitive System Where Young People Are Dragged Into Court For Minor Offenses And Girls Are Punished Far More Severely Than Boys. Thorough, Timely, And Persuasive, Justice For Girls? Will Be Vital To Anyone Working With Troubled Youths.--jacket. Criminal Girls And Girls In Youth Justice -- Are Sugar And Spice Really Evolving Into Snips And Snails And Puppy-dog Tails? -- Paternalism And The Social Control Of Adolescent Girls: Juvenile Justice Reform In The United States -- Paternalism And The Social Control Of Adolescent Girls: Juvenile Justice Reform In Canada -- The Impact Of Law Reform: Deinstitutionalization In Law And Practice In The United States -- The Impact Of Law Reform: Deinstitutionalization In Law And Practice In Canada -- Continuity And Change In Justice For Girls -- Appendixes. Jane B. Sprott And Anthony N. Doob ; With A Foreword By Franklin E. Zimring. Includes Bibliographical References (p. [199]-208) And Index. Contents ......Page 6 Foreword by Franklin E. Zimring......Page 8 Acknowledgments......Page 12 1. Criminal Girls and Girls in Youth Justice ......Page 14 2. Are Sugar and Spice Really Evolving into Snips and Snails and Puppy-Dog Tails? ......Page 32 3. Paternalism and the Social Control of Adolescent Girls: Juvenile Justice Reform in the United States......Page 57 4. Paternalism and the Social Control of Adolescent Girls: Juvenile Justice Reform in Canada ......Page 87 5. The Impact of Law Reform: Deinstitutionalization in Law and Practice in the United States ......Page 111 6. The Impact of Law Reform: Deinstitutionalization in Law and Practice in Canada ......Page 141 7. Continuity and Change in Justice for Girls ......Page 171 Appendixes ......Page 188 Notes ......Page 204 References ......Page 212 Index ......Page 222 This book is a comparative study of the way the United States and Canada have responded to the hysteria over "girl crime" and how it has affected the treatment of both girls and boys. The authors trace the evolution of approaches to the treatment of young offenders