Jung and Kierkegaard: Researching a Kindred Spirit in the Shadows (Research in Analytical Psychology and Jungian Studies)

Jung and Kierkegaard identifies authenticity, suffering and self-deception as the three key themes that connect the work of Carl Jung and Søren Kierkegaard. There is, in the thinking of these pioneering psychologists of the human condition, a fundamental belief in the healing potential of a religious outlook. This engaging and erudite text explores the significance of the similarities of thinking between Kierkegaard and Jung, bridging the gap between the former’s particular brand of existential Christian psychology and the latter’s own unique philosophy. Given the similarity of their work and experiences that were common to both of their personal biographies, particularly the relationship that each had with his father, one might expect Jung to have found in Kierkegaard a kindred spirit. Yet this was not the case, and Jung viewed Kierkegaard with great scorn. That there exists such a strong comparison and extensive overlap in the life and thought of these towering figures of psychology and philosophy leads us to question why it is that Jung so strongly rejected Kierkegaard. Such hostility is particularly fascinating given the striking similarity that Jung’s own analytical psychology bears to the Christian psychology upheld by Kierkegaard. Cook’s thought-provoking book fills a very real gap in Jungian scholarship and is the first attempt to undertake a direct comparison between Jung and Kierkegaard’s models of development. It is therefore essential reading for academics and postgraduate students with an interest in Jungian and Kierkegaard scholarship, as well as psychology, philosophy and religion more generally. About the Author Amy Cook graduated with a degree in History from the University of Aberdeen in 2005. She then went on to study a masters in Philosophy and Psychoanalysis at Essex University before completing another masters in Jungian and Post-Jungian Studies. After a brief spell teaching overseas, Amy returned to the UK and began a PhD at Bangor University. She currently lives in North Wales, where she works with young carers to support and encourage them to fulfil their full potential. "Jung and Kierkegaard identifies authenticity, suffering and self-deception as the three key themes that connect the work of Carl Jung and Søren Kierkegaard. There is, in the thinking of these pioneering psychologists of the human condition, a fundamental belief in the healing potential of a religious outlook. This engaging and erudite text explores the significance of the similarities of thinking between Kierkegaard and Jung, bridging the gap between the former's particular brand of existential Christian psychology and the latter's own unique philosophy. Given the similarity of their work and experiences that were common to both of their personal biographies, particularly the relationship that each had with his father, one might expect Jung to have found in Kierkegaard a kindred spirit. Yet this was not the case, and Jung viewed Kierkegaard with great scorn. That there exists such a strong comparison and extensive overlap in the life and thought of these towering figures of psychology and philosophy leads us to question why it is that Jung so strongly rejected Kierkegaard. Such hostility is particularly fascinating given the striking similarity that Jung's own analytical psychology bears to the Christian psychology upheld by Kierkegaard. Cook's thought-provoking book fills a very real gap in Jungian scholarship and is the first attempt to undertake a direct comparison between Jung and Kierkegaard's models of development. It is therefore essential reading for academics and postgraduate students with an interest in Jungian and Kierkegaard scholarship, as well as psychology, philosophy and religion more generally."--Provided by publisher Jung And Kierkegaard Identifies Authenticity, Suffering And Self-deception As The Three Key Themes That Connect The Work Of Carl Jung And Soren Kierkegaard. There Is, In The Thinking Of These Pioneering Psychologists Of The Human Condition, A Fundamental Belief In The Healing Potential Of A Religious Outlook. This Engaging And Erudite Text Explores The Significance Of The Similarities Of Thinking Between Kierkegaard And Jung, Bridging The Gap Between The Former's Particular Brand Of Existential Christian Psychology And The Latter's Own Unique Philosophy. Given The Similarity Of Their Work And Experiences That Were Common To Both Of Their Personal Biographies, Particularly The Relationship That Each Had With His Father, One Might Expect Jung To Have Found In Kierkegaard A Kindred Spirit. Yet This Was Not The Case, And Jung Viewed Kierkegaard With Great Scorn. That There Exists Such A Strong Comparison And Extensive Overlap In The Life And Thought Of These Towering Figures Of Psychology And Philosophy Leads Us To Question Why It Is That Jung So Strongly Rejected Kierkegaard. Such Hostility Is Particularly Fascinating Given The Striking Similarity That Jung's Own Analytical Psychology Bears To The Christian Psychology Upheld By Kierkegaard. Cook's Thought-provoking Book Fills A Very Real Gap In Jungian Scholarship And Is The First Attempt To Undertake A Direct Comparison Between Jung And Kierkegaard's Models Of Development. It Is Therefore Essential Reading For Academics And Postgraduate Students With An Interest In Jungian And Kierkegaard Scholarship, As Well As Psychology, Philosophy And Religion More Generally. Amy Cook. Part Part 1 -- chapter PART 1 Introduction -- chapter 1 A holy kind of healing -- chapter 2 Some striking similarities: personal and philosophical -- chapter 3 Introducing Kierkegaard -- chapter 4 Presenting Jung -- chapter 5 The wounds of the father: a shared inheritance -- part Part 2 -- chapter 6 An unconventional Christianity -- chapter 7 Jung and religion -- chapter 8 The therapeutic value of faith -- chapter 9 Grounding ethics in spirit: the medium of our self-realisation -- chapter 10 Suffering and the pain of personal growth: perrissem, nisi perissem -- chapter 11 Authenticity: the creation of one's genuine self -- part Part 3 -- chapter 12 'That Religious Neurotic': Kierkegaard on the couch -- chapter 13 Keeping mum: a powerful silence -- chapter 14 Søren's spiritual castration: a father's influence -- chapter 15 To marry or to martyr -- chapter 16 The final years of Søren Kierkegaard: a story of archetypal compensation -- part Part 4 -- chapter 17 The nature of a Kierkegaardian neurosis: Jung's reception of Kierkegaard -- chapter 18 Kierkegaard and Nietzsche: polar opposites in the mind of Jung -- chapter 19 Summary of discussion -- chapter 20 Conclusion Cover -- Title -- Copyright -- Dedication -- Contents -- Acknowledgements -- Part 1 -- Introduction -- 1 A holy kind of healing -- 2 Some striking similarities: personal and philosophical -- 3 Introducing Kierkegaard -- 4 Presenting Jung -- 5 The wounds of the father: a shared inheritance -- Part 2 -- 6 An unconventional Christianity -- 7 Jung and religion -- 8 The therapeutic value of faith -- 9 Grounding ethics in spirit: the medium of our self-realisation -- 10 Suffering and the pain of personal growth: perrissem, nisi perissem -- 11 Authenticity: the creation of one's genuine self -- Part 3 -- 12 'That Religious Neurotic': Kierkegaard on the couch -- 13 Keeping mum: a powerful silence -- 14 Søren's spiritual castration: a father's influence -- 15 To marry or to martyr -- 16 The final years of Søren Kierkegaard: a story of archetypal compensation -- Part 4 -- 17 The nature of a Kierkegaardian neurosis: Jung's reception of Kierkegaard -- 18 Kierkegaard and Nietzsche: polar opposites in the mind of Jung -- 19 Summary of discussion -- 20 Conclusion -- Epilogue: Jung and Kierkegaard: a legacy considered -- Bibliography -- Index