Euthanasia in the Netherlands: The Policy and Practice of Mercy Killing (International Library of Ethics, Law, and the New Medicine Book 20)

The Dutch experience has influenced the debate on euthanasia and death with dignity around the globe, especially with regard to whether physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia should be legitimized or legalized. A review of the literature reveals complex and often contradictory views about the Dutch experience. Some claim that the Netherlands offers a model for the world to follow; others believe that the Netherlands represents danger, rather than promise, and that the Dutch experience is the definitive answer regarding why we should not make active euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide part of our lives. Given these contradictory views, it has become clear that fieldwork is essential to developing a more informed opinion. Having investigated the Dutch experience for a number of years, and after thoroughly reading the vast literature published in English, I went to the Netherlands for one month in the summer of 1999 to get a feel for the local situation. I felt that this would provide the basis on which I could better interpret the findings of the available literature. I visited the major centers of medical ethics, as well as some research hospitals, and spoke with leading figures in the euthanasia policy and practice. The time spent was extremely beneficial and enriching. I followed in the footsteps of Carlos Gomez, who 1 published a book following one month of extensive research in the Netherlands. This Book Is A Must-read For Anyone Who Wishes To Understand The Pitfalls Of Policy-making Where Euthanasia And Physician-assisted Suicide Are Concerned. This Book Will Be Most Useful In Academic Forums, And It Will Appeal To Legislatures And Judges Who Take The Decisions And Make The Judgments Necessary To Protect The Fabric Of Society In The Face Of Technological Medicine. In Addition, This Book Is Of Relevance To Medical Doctors, Ethicists, Lawyers Working In The Field Of Medical Law And Ethics, And Sociologists Who Are Interested In End-of-life Issues And Social Justice.--jacket. Pt. A. Background -- Ch. 1. The Three Research Reports Of 1990, 1995 And 2001, And Their Interpretations -- Ch. 2. The Practice Of Euthanasia And The Legal Framework -- Pt. B. Fieldwork -- Ch. 3. The Methodology -- Phase I: The Interviews -- Ch. 4. Why The Netherlands? -- Ch. 5. Views On The Practice Of Euthanasia -- Ch. 6. Worrisome Data -- Ch. 7. The Remmelink Contention And The British Criticism -- Ch. 8. Should Physicians Suggest Euthanasia To Their Patients? -- Ch. 9. Breaches Of The Guidelines -- Ch. 10. On Palliative Care And The Dutch Culture -- Ch. 11. On Legislation And The Chabot Case -- Phase Ii: Interviewees' General Comments -- Phase Iii: Updates -- Pt. C. Conclusion. By Raphael Cohen-almagor. Includes Bibliographical References And Indexes. This book is a must for anyone who wishes to understand the pitfalls of policy-making where euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are concerned. The book will be most useful in academic forums, and it will appeal to legislatures and judges who take the decisions and make the judgments necessary to protect the fabric of society in the face of technological medicine. In addition, this book is of relevance to medical doctors, ethicists, lawyers working in the field of medical law and ethics, and sociologists who are interested in end-of-life issues and social justice. Euthanasia in the Netherlands: - addresses an issue that is of growing concern in North America and Europe; - offers an interdisciplinary, compelling study in medicine, law, religion and ethics; - covers a wide range of theoretical and practical issues concerning the end of life; - considers the philosophical difficulties inherent in the concepts of medical ethics; - is not confined strictly to the philosophical realm; - is based on interviews conducted in hospitals, research centers and universities in the Netherlands - will contribute to the ongoing debate about the intricate questions of medical ethics; - deals with issues that bring scholars and students, politicians, sociologists, jurist and lawyers together Front Matter....Pages i-xiii Preliminaries: Comparative Law....Pages 1-20 Front Matter....Pages 21-21 The Three Research Reports of 1990, 1995 and 2001, and Their Interpretations....Pages 23-33 The Practice of Euthanasia and The Legal Framework....Pages 35-49 Front Matter....Pages 51-51 The Methodology....Pages 53-56 Why The Netherlands?....Pages 57-63 Views on the Practice of Euthanasia....Pages 65-73 Worrisome Data....Pages 75-84 The Remmelink Contention and the British Criticism....Pages 85-90 Should Physicians Suggest Euthanasia To Their Patients?....Pages 91-101 Breaches of the Guidelines....Pages 103-121 On Palliative Care and the Dutch Culture....Pages 123-132 On Legislation and the CHABOT Case....Pages 133-144 Back Matter....Pages 145-205