Education Without the State

Functional illiteracy, youth delinquency and lack of technological innovation all point to the failures of state schooling. They raise the question of why governments should be involved in education at all. One justification for state intervention in education is that, without it, there would not be educational opportunities for all. However, the great majority of people would not need state intervention for funding or provision of educational opportunities. Intervention would at most be required for a minority in need of financial support. This conclusion is supported by historical evidence from Victorian England and Wales, and from more recent experience around the world, of educational entrepreneurs stepping in to provide desired opportunities where state education is failing. A second justification offered is that equality of opportunity requires state intervention in education. When the record is examined, it is not clear that states anywhere have been able to provide equality. Strong theoretical arguments undermine the suggestion that they ever would. Moreover, arguments against 'markets' in schooling which purport to show how they increase inequality actually point to problems not with markets, but with state regulation and provision themselves. Many influential philosophers and economists agree that justice or fairness requires that everyone has adequate opportunities. But markets - with a funding safety-net - could provide adequate opportunities for all, and more effectively than further state intervention. A final justification is that state regulation of, inter alia, the curriculum is required. Lessons from the recent history of the national curriculum illustrate the general undesirability of government intervention in the curriculum. The problems of 'competing visions' and the 'knowledge problem' and considerations of the nature of education point to the folly of not leaving decisions to parents and young people themselves. If state intervention in... Public schooling is as close to the official religion of the United States as any institution is ever likely to be. And if you are reading this eBook, you are likely a heretic. Education Without the State brings together some of the conversations I’ve had about education on the Tom Woods Show, my weekday podcast. Five days a week I cover some aspect of libertarianism. That gives me a treasure trove of material on which I can draw to assemble eBooks like this one. PUBLIC SCHOOLING IS THE AMERICAN RELIGION. ARE YOU A HERETIC? You've heard the so-called arguments. Nearly everyone would be an illiterate moron without the state. Only the super-rich would be educated. And so on. E.G. West demolished these silly claims half a century ago. James Tooley is refuting them today: low-cost private schools are in fact educating the world's poor, and progressives know nothing about it. Discover the truth in this free eBook by New York Times bestselling author Tom Woods.