Counter-Movements in the Sciences: The Sociology of the Alternatives to Big Science (Sociology of the Sciences Yearbook Book 3)

Heretical thoughts in an orthodox series on sociology of the sciences? Devils and science between the covers of one book? Games with ambivalence to mask collective uncertainty? We anticipate similar future reactions from readers or reviewers when assessing the way in which this volume has been assembled. But writings on counter-science, like the history of colonialism, are usually written by the winners, therefore unequivocally partial and only too often lacking in social imagination. In seeking to redress the balance, we admit to having been fully receptive to the latter, of having displayed an un­ measured degree of sympathy with heretics and outsiders, including practising scientists, and to letting science defend itself. The antithetical relationship implied in the volume's title - Counter-movements in the Sciences - stands for what we regard as an ongoing, open-ended process. In collecting material for this volume, we have brought together voices speaking from different quarters: there are those who, although modestly claiming to speak only for them­ selves, have set out to question sacred assumptions of scientific faith or to cast doubt on well-known claims scientific knowledge holds over other forms of knowledge; others have undertaken to demonstrate the fragility, ifnot untenability of attempts at demarcation between science and other systems of belief or practice or shown that demarcations between different forms of rationality rest on other than methodological grounds; finally, those who wish to re-arrange, by mapping out some meta-point of surveillance, familiar territory, showing the need for rearrangement and Front Matter....Pages i-xv Science and Its Critics: Reflections on Anti-Science....Pages 1-26 Anti-Establishment Science in Some British Journals....Pages 27-37 Knowledge and Opinions....Pages 39-56 Can the Unity of Sciences be Considered as the Norm of Sciences?....Pages 57-66 Guardians at the Frontiers of Science....Pages 67-104 Alternatives in Science — Alternatives to Science?....Pages 105-125 Counter-Movements and the Sciences: Theses Supporting Counter-Movements to the ‘Scientisation of the World’....Pages 127-146 Science and Ignorance....Pages 147-160 it may be that on earth no one speaks the truth....Pages 161-184 Resistance to the Machine....Pages 185-220 Is Anti-Science not-Science?....Pages 221-250 Organic Farmers Celebrate Organic Research: A Sociology of Popular Science....Pages 251-275 Hyper-Reflexivity — a New Danger for the Counter-Movements....Pages 277-289 Back Matter....Pages 291-293