Acute Religious Experiences: Madness, Psychosis and Religious Studies (Bloomsbury Advances in Religious Studies)

How do we explain the coincidence of religion and madness in which prophets, founders of religions and great saints often show symptoms of an excitability that is extreme and even pathological? This book attempts to address this phenomenological problem. Richard Saville-Smith argues that ‘acute religious experiences’ provides a novel category to the study of the non-rational. This book provides an epidemiological approach to a crisis, which is non-veridical and non-reductionist, recognizing a predisposition due to gene variation as a perennial constant, whilst affirming that culture contextualizes experiences. Informed by contemporary psychiatric theory, which is passed through the lens of mad studies, this book proposes the ‘sweet-spot’ of ‘acute religious experiences’ which express the phenomenality of madness – but where mad is good. This interdisciplinary study provides a species-wide account of interest to all disciplines that encounter such anomalies in their subjects, from fine art to psychiatry. This book engages the problem of how, in the 21st century, we are to speak about experiences of the extraordinary/anomalous/extreme which occur on a transhistorical and transcultural basis. Critical re-readings of seminal texts show how 20th-century theoreticians in the humanities sought to erase madness from their irrational subjects. This propensity to sanitize madness in the study of religions was mirrored by the instinct of psychiatrists to degrade religious experiences by reducing mad consciousness to psychosis or dissociation. Richard Saville-Smith introduces explanatory pluralism as a way of recognizing these disciplinary biases and mad studies as a way of negotiating this understanding. The disproportionate significance of madness in shaping the fabric of the human story can then be recovered from both erasure and dismissal to be given the recognition previously denied - as acute religious experiences. Acute Religious Experiences divides into three sections, beginning with re-readings of William James's pathological programme, Rudolf Otto's numinous, T. K. Oesterreich's possession, Mircea Eliade's shamanism, Walter Stace's mysticism, Walter Pahnke's psychedelic experience, and Abraham Maslow's peak experiences. These ideas are shown to constitute the beginnings of a fractured discourse on the irrational. In part two, contemporary psychiatry's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) and Foucault's History of Madness are re-read to reposition madness as not necessarily pathological. This opens the way for the identification of acute religious experiences as a new holistic and post-colonial approach through which religious data can be organized and addressed on a comparative basis. In part three, The Gospel of Mark is re-read as a case study to demonstrate the novel insights which flow from the identification of acute religious experiences. Richard Saville-Smith draws on his own experiences of madness and his PhD from the School of Divinity at The University of Edinburgh to elucidate his research. Half Title Series Page Title Page Copyright Page Dedication Contents Figures Acknowledgements Introduction Part I: Theoreticians of a not necessarily pathological discourse Chapter 1: William James’s Pathological Programme Chapter 2: Rudolf Otto’s Numinous Chapter 3: T. K. Oesterreich’s Possession Chapter 4: Mircea Eliade’s Shamanism Chapter 5: Walter Stace’s Mysticism Chapter 6: Walter Pahnke’s Psychedelic Experience Chapter 7: Abraham Maslow’s Peak Experiences Part II: From psychiatry to madness to acute religious experiences Chapter 8: The American Psychiatric Association’s DSM-5 Chapter 9: Michel Foucault’s History of Madness Chapter 10: Acute Religious Experiences Part III: Jesus as a case study Chapter 11: Re-reading the Gospel of Mark Conclusion Notes Bibliography Index